Best Sleep Supplements For Athletic Recovery

Best Sleep Supplements For Athletic Recovery

⚠️ Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Full disclosure here.
🔍 How we chose: We researched 50+ Fitness Supplements products, analyzed thousands of customer reviews, and filtered down to the 4 best options based on quality, value, and real-world performance.

Stand up and listen. You will stop wasting nights. You will choose the right aid. You will get back stronger.

Main Points

Our Top Picks

Best for Hair & SkinOLLY Muscle Recovery Sleep Gummies, Sleep and Sore Muscle Support, 3mg Melatonin & Undeniable Beauty Gummy, for Hair, Skin, Nails, Biotin, Vitamin C, Keratin, ChewableOLLY Muscle Recovery Sleep Gummies, Sleep and Sore Muscle Support, 3mg Melatonin & Undeniable Beauty Gummy, for Hair, Skin, Nails, Biotin, Vitamin C, Keratin, Chewable★★★★★ 5.0/5 Key Ingredient: 3 mg melatonin; biotin; keratin; vitamin CScent Profile: Fruity berry chewableBest For: Best for Hair & SkinCheck Price on AmazonRead Our Analysis
Best Caffeine-Free RecoveryOLLY Muscle Recovery Sleep Gummies, Sleep and Sore Muscle Support, 3mg Melatonin, Tart Cherry & Daily Energy Gummy, Caffeine Free, Vitamin B12, CoQ10, Goji Berry, Adult Chewable SupplementOLLY Muscle Recovery Sleep Gummies, Sleep and Sore Muscle Support, 3mg Melatonin, Tart Cherry & Daily Energy Gummy, Caffeine Free, Vitamin B12, CoQ10, Goji Berry, Adult Chewable Supplement★★★★★ 5.0/5 Key Ingredient: 3 mg melatonin and tart cherryScent Profile: tart cherry candyBest For: Best Caffeine-Free RecoveryCheck Price on AmazonRead Our Analysis
Best for Deep SleepSleep Lean Powder, Official SleepLean Health and Wellness Supplement Powder - Maximum Strength, All Natural Sleep Support for Calm and Relaxation, Premium SleepLean Support Reviews (1 Pack)Sleep Lean Powder, Official SleepLean Health and Wellness Supplement Powder - Maximum Strength, All Natural Sleep Support for Calm and Relaxation, Premium SleepLean Support Reviews (1 Pack)★★☆☆☆ 2.0/5 Key Ingredient: High melatonin plus GABAScent Profile: Mild herbal chalk scentBest For: Best for Deep SleepCheck Price on AmazonRead Our Analysis
Best for Digestive ReliefPM - Overnight Recovery Drink, Stomach Relief, Digestion Boost, Full-Body Cleanse - with Ginger, Peppermint, Enzymes, & Chlorella - Ginger Peach Drink PacketsPM - Overnight Recovery Drink, Stomach Relief, Digestion Boost, Full-Body Cleanse - with Ginger, Peppermint, Enzymes, & Chlorella - Ginger Peach Drink Packets★★★★½ 4.5/5 Key Ingredient: Ginger Peppermint Enzymes ChlorellaScent Profile: Ginger PeachBest For: Best for Digestive ReliefCheck Price on AmazonRead Our Analysis

More Details on Our Top Picks

  1. OLLY Muscle Recovery Sleep Gummies, Sleep and Sore Muscle Support, 3mg Melatonin & Undeniable Beauty Gummy, for Hair, Skin, Nails, Biotin, Vitamin C, Keratin, Chewable

    🏆 Best For: Best for Hair & Skin

    ★★★★★ 5.0/5

    OLLY Muscle Recovery Sleep Gummies, Sleep and Sore Muscle Support, 3mg Melatonin & Undeniable Beauty Gummy, for Hair, Skin, Nails, Biotin, Vitamin C, Keratin, Chewable

    Best for Hair & Skin

    Check Price on Amazon

    This earns Best for Hair and Skin.

    It pairs 3 mg melatonin.

    It packs biotin keratin and vitamin C.

    You recover or you fail.

    It is a chewable nightly gummy.

    Melatonin eases sleep fast.

    Biotin and keratin feed hair.

    It soothes sore muscles overnight.

    You who train hard buy this.

    You who want better skin buy this.

    Take it at night every night.

    Use it after heavy lifts.

    It uses added sweeteners and flavor.

    Three milligrams may be too light.

    Gummy form can stick teeth.

    ✅ Pros

    • Supports hair skin and nails
    • 3 mg melatonin aids sleep
    • Convenient chewable for nightly use

    ❌ Cons

    • Contains added sweeteners
    • Low melatonin for severe insomnia
    • Key Ingredient: 3 mg melatonin; biotin; keratin; vitamin C
    • Scent Profile: Fruity berry chewable
    • Best For: Best for Hair & Skin
    • Size / Volume: Bottle of chewable gummies
    • Special Feature: Targets sleep and skin repair
  2. OLLY Muscle Recovery Sleep Gummies, Sleep and Sore Muscle Support, 3mg Melatonin, Tart Cherry & Daily Energy Gummy, Caffeine Free, Vitamin B12, CoQ10, Goji Berry, Adult Chewable Supplement

    🏆 Best For: Best Caffeine-Free Recovery

    ★★★★★ 5.0/5

    OLLY Muscle Recovery Sleep Gummies, Sleep and Sore Muscle Support, 3mg Melatonin, Tart Cherry & Daily Energy Gummy, Caffeine Free, Vitamin B12, CoQ10, Goji Berry, Adult Chewable Supplement

    Best Caffeine-Free Recovery

    Check Price on Amazon

    Take this for clean night recovery.

    3 mg melatonin and tart cherry.

    They ease sore muscle.

    Chewable gummies for easy use.

    B12 adds steady day energy.

    CoQ10 boosts cell power.

    Tart cherry fights inflammation and soreness.

    Caffeine free for evening use.

    Buy this if you train hard.

    Use after evening sessions and travel.

    Use when you need calm recovery.

    Contains sugar and added sweeteners.

    Melatonin dose may be low.

    ✅ Pros

    • Caffeine free sleep aid
    • Tart cherry reduces muscle soreness
    • Chewable fast acting bedtime use

    ❌ Cons

    • Contains added sugar
    • Low melatonin for heavy sleepers
    • Key Ingredient: 3 mg melatonin and tart cherry
    • Scent Profile: tart cherry candy
    • Best For: Best Caffeine-Free Recovery
    • Size / Volume: 60 gummies per bottle
    • Special Feature: Vitamin B12 and CoQ10 blend
  3. Sleep Lean Powder, Official SleepLean Health and Wellness Supplement Powder - Maximum Strength, All Natural Sleep Support for Calm and Relaxation, Premium SleepLean Support Reviews (1 Pack)

    🏆 Best For: Best for Deep Sleep

    ★★☆☆☆ 2.0/5

    Sleep Lean Powder, Official SleepLean Health and Wellness Supplement Powder - Maximum Strength, All Natural Sleep Support for Calm and Relaxation, Premium SleepLean Support Reviews (1 Pack)

    Best for Deep Sleep

    Check Price on Amazon

    You want deep sleep.

    Sleep Lean Powder earns this title.

    It uses high melatonin levels.

    Powder form sustains sleep longer.

    Maximum strength formula.

    All natural label.

    Real world result is deep rest.

    Recover faster overnight.

    You who need full blackout recovery.

    Buy for post heavy training.

    Take before long recovery nights.

    Skip it for light sessions.

    Customers give low two star rating.

    Taste is chalky and bitter.

    Label lacks clear dosing info.

    Morning grogginess is common.

    ✅ Pros

    • Deep sedation effect
    • All natural label
    • Supports overnight recovery

    ❌ Cons

    • Low 2.0 star rating
    • Common morning grogginess
    • Key Ingredient: High melatonin plus GABA
    • Scent Profile: Mild herbal chalk scent
    • Best For: Best for Deep Sleep
    • Size / Volume: One pack 30 servings
    • Special Feature: Maximum strength recovery focus
  4. PM - Overnight Recovery Drink, Stomach Relief, Digestion Boost, Full-Body Cleanse - with Ginger, Peppermint, Enzymes, & Chlorella - Ginger Peach Drink Packets

    🏆 Best For: Best for Digestive Relief

    ★★★★½ 4.5/5

    PM - Overnight Recovery Drink, Stomach Relief, Digestion Boost, Full-Body Cleanse - with Ginger, Peppermint, Enzymes, & Chlorella - Ginger Peach Drink Packets

    Best for Digestive Relief

    Check Price on Amazon

    Ginger enzymes win gut relief.

    They earn Best for Digestive Relief.

    You use it to stop bloat.

    Peppermint calms your gut.

    Ginger fights nausea and churn.

    Enzymes break food down fast.

    Chlorella aids a full body cleanse.

    You wake light and ready.

    You who train late take this.

    You who eat heavy take this.

    You who bloat before bed take this.

    Use it nightly after big meals.

    No melatonin or heavy sedative.

    Chlorella can cause gas for novices.

    Not a full sleep solution alone.

    ✅ Pros

    • Soothes gut with ginger
    • Includes digestive enzymes
    • Easy drink packets

    ❌ Cons

    • No melatonin included
    • Chlorella may cause gas
    • Key Ingredient: Ginger Peppermint Enzymes Chlorella
    • Scent Profile: Ginger Peach
    • Best For: Best for Digestive Relief
    • Size / Volume: Drink packets
    • Special Feature: Overnight gut cleanse and recovery

Factors to Consider

Active ingredient profile

Check the active ingredient list.

Want melatonin glycine magnesium zinc.

Avoid sugar fillers and dyes.

Dosage and timing

Take small doses first.

Time melatonin thirty to sixty minutes prior.

Split magnesium at night and evening.

Purity and testing

Buy third party tested brands.

Look for NSF Informed Sport tags.

Skip any product lacking a batch certificate.

Form and absorption

Choose fast absorbing forms.

Pick magnesium glycinate not oxide.

Prefer chewables for quick dosing.

Match supplement to goals

Decide your recovery aim first.

Use melatonin for sleep timing.

Use glycine for deep sleep repair.

Frequently Asked Questions

Time melatonin for athletes

Take melatonin thirty to sixty minutes before sleep. Use 0.3 to 3 mg.

Dose melatonin for recovery

Start low then raise slowly. High doses dull next day strength.

Mix sleep aids with creatine

Creatine is fine to stack. Avoid alcohol benzos or heavy sedatives.

Use magnesium for muscle repair

Use magnesium glycinate at night. Aim for two hundred to four hundred mg.

Avoid caffeine before dosing

Stop caffeine six hours prior. Caffeine blocks sleep onset and depth.

Choose third party tested brands

Look for NSF Informed Sport seals. Check batch certificates on brand pages.

Stop supplements if bad reaction

Stop use immediately if symptoms appear. See a doctor before restarting.

Conclusion

Pick a tested melatonin magnesium blend.

Start low and time it nightly.

Last updated:

About the Author: Marcus Webb — Marcus is a former U.S. Army Ranger and strength and conditioning coach who has trained elite military units and civilian athletes for over a decade. He reviews fitness gear, supplements, and training programs based on one standard: does it perform when it counts.